The All-Conference teams were selected by coaches from the FCSAA's Division I Citrus and Panhandle Conferences. 

In addition to a first- and second-team, coaches selected the following individual awards:

• Citrus Conference Players of the Year: Caroline Mito, Miami Dade; Avery Velazquez, Eastern Florida State
• Panhandle Conference Player of the Year: Sister Arnold, Northwest Florida State 
• Citrus Conference Pitcher of the Year: J'dah Girigorie, Indian River State; Shaylen Byrd, Seminole State
• Panhandle Conference Pitcher of the Year: Cailyn Heyl, Northwest Florida State

By virtue of winning their respective conferences, Florida SouthWestern's Robert Iamurri and Northwest Florida State's Andy Lee were recognized as the Coach of the Year for the Citrus and Panhandle, respectively.

The FCSAA Division I Softball Awards will be announced at 2 p.m., Monday, May 5.  

All-Citrus Conference 

First-team 

Infield: Caroline Mito, Miami Dade; Virginia Mambelli, Florida SouthWestern; Emily Allegood, Florida SouthWestern; Sarah Phipps, Indian River State; Thaima Maximiliana, Indian River State; Izzy LaRoche, Seminole State; Leah Clark, Central Florida; Azlynn Gomes, Daytona State; Jessica Merk, Eastern Florida State; Morgan Davis, Daytona State

Outfield: Skylar Brennan, Florida SouthWestern; Noelani Livingstone, Florida SouthWestern; Braylee Shields, Indian River State; Ella Carroll, St. Petersburg; Karris Rhine, Santa Fe; Madison Conway, Santa Fe; Aracelis Jimenez, Eastern Florida State; Aurielle Reavis, Daytona State

Catcher: Presley Smith, Indian River State; Alyssa Filmer, St. Petersburg; Makayla Nieves, Seminole State

Pitcher: J'dah Girigorie, Indian River State; Leah Meyer, Florida SouthWestern; Carina Amarilla, Miami Dade; Lizzy Kwakernaak, Florida SouthWestern; Shaylen Byrd, Seminole State; Ava Unser, Daytona State; Ryleigh Bauer, Santa Fe; Ryleigh Bennett, Santa Fe

At-Large: Kassidy Pontbriant, Indian River State; Nicole Edmiaston, Florida SouthWestern; Avery Velazquez, Eastern Florida State; McKenzie Jewell, Santa Fe; Madison VanAllen, Central Florida

Second-team

Infield: Kmari Williams, Florida SouthWestern; Vanessa Neptune, Hillsborough; Maria Julia Pedroso, Miami Dade; Belen Gomez, Hillsborough; Ebba Sofia Eriksson, Miami Dade; Amber Daughtry, Central Florida; Izzy Otero, Eastern Florida State; Tegan Grizzard, Santa Fe; Nayeli Hernandez, Polk State

Outfield: Megan Veilleux, Florida SouthWestern; Anaise Piar, Indian River State; Dana Piri, Miami Dade; Loren Tucker, St. Petersburg; Chelsi Rae Herbert, Polk State; Bailey Holmes, Central Florida; Karyna Lewis, Polk State; Logan Ringel, Daytona State

Catcher: Faith Warthon, Florida SouthWestern; Gabriela Luz, Miami Dade; Kaili Cannon, Daytona State

Pitcher: Amanda Handa, Miami Dade; Hanna Deschambault, Indian River State; McKenzie Bailey-McDowell, Florida SouthWestern; Zoe Yzaguirre, Florida SouthWestern; Samantha Titzel, Seminole State; Kaylee Martineau, Daytona State; Belle Mancillas, Santa Fe; Luci Walters, Eastern Florida State

At-Large: Olivia Rogers, St. Petersburg; Hezenia Seabrook, Indian River State; Anna Green, Seminole State; Leia Hurst, Polk State; Kiara Beltre, Seminole State

All-Panhandle Conference 

First-team 

Infield: Sister Arnold, Northwest Florida State; Irene Rabasco, Chipola; Katelyn Morgan, Pensacola State; Karson McGowan, Northwest Florida State; Aniyah Stokes, Gulf Coast State

Outfield: Falyn Beebe, Northwest Florida State; Diana Arcay, Chipola; Haley Hughes, Northwest Florida State; Macy Robinette, Gulf Coast State

Catcher: Cailyn Cooke, Gulf Coast State; Hailey Henry, Northwest Florida State

Pitcher: Cailyn Heyl, Northwest Florida State; Mallory Baker, Northwest Florida State; Kaylee Navarre, Gulf Coast State; Yala Zwakman, Pensacola State

At-Large: Lulu Luedtke, Northwest Florida State; Anyela Gomez, Chipola

Second-team

Infield: Kayla Franklin, Chipola; Bri Hughes, Northwest Florida State; Mallory Collier, Tallahassee State; Ally Henderson, Gulf Coast State; Emily Chandler, Gulf Coast State

Outfield: Gabbie York, Pensacola State; Kamryn Eaton, Chipola; Hayden Andrews, Northwest Florida State; Asia Peart, Tallahassee State

Catcher: Addison Carter, Chipola; Keara Millinder, Chipola

Pitcher: Ainsley Stubbs, Gulf Coast State; Hannah Worthington, Chipola; Kylie Jarman, Pensacola State; Lauren Grantham, Chipola

At-Large: Rosalie Dufresne, Tallahassee State; Victoria Richardson, Tallahassee State